Thursday, April 28, 2005
Culture belongs to which people????
As I delve deeper into the "Cultural Analysis" of India, I begin to fear that we (In-Resident-Indians) are being propelled into looking at our culture as an expat-NRI-immigrant would.
Indian literature is largely dominated by immigrant Indian writers in English - Amitav Ghosh, Jumpha Lahiri, Rohinton Mistry, Shashi Tharoor, Vikram Seth, Naipaul etc. The marketability of these books in Indian are enormous, they are Indian writers isn't it?
I appreciate these writers for building up stories around India.Alas! Their stories are all too ethnic to a point of being termed backward in the modern context.Even diasporic films are dominated by these stories.
Bollywood films, the largest Indian cultural icon is now catering to suit NRI audiences, so Indian Directors are beginning to say stories that the NRI's want to hear - the story between trendy and traditional.
With cross over films like "Bend it like Beckham" and "Bride and Prejudice" directed by diasporic film makers becoming box office hits,it is the same story of portraying India as a land of the exotic and ethnic, therefore an amusing diversion, but not providing an authentic version of contemporary India.
So the culture version of "India" is now being largely defined by diasporic intellectuals. Where do the resident Indians figure?
I would love to hear views.
Indian literature is largely dominated by immigrant Indian writers in English - Amitav Ghosh, Jumpha Lahiri, Rohinton Mistry, Shashi Tharoor, Vikram Seth, Naipaul etc. The marketability of these books in Indian are enormous, they are Indian writers isn't it?
I appreciate these writers for building up stories around India.Alas! Their stories are all too ethnic to a point of being termed backward in the modern context.Even diasporic films are dominated by these stories.
Bollywood films, the largest Indian cultural icon is now catering to suit NRI audiences, so Indian Directors are beginning to say stories that the NRI's want to hear - the story between trendy and traditional.
With cross over films like "Bend it like Beckham" and "Bride and Prejudice" directed by diasporic film makers becoming box office hits,it is the same story of portraying India as a land of the exotic and ethnic, therefore an amusing diversion, but not providing an authentic version of contemporary India.
So the culture version of "India" is now being largely defined by diasporic intellectuals. Where do the resident Indians figure?
I would love to hear views.
Comments
Thank you for visiting Harleys, Cars, Girls & Guitars.
I live in Jersey City, which is just across the river from Manhattan. Also have a house upstate in Woodstock. Jersey City is a major point of entry into the U.S. for Indians. Has a very good Indian shopping district.
A similar phenomenon to the one you've described, the runaways dominating the arts, is also true in the U.S. Kids flee the small towns of the midwest and the south to live in New York City, Los Angeles and San Francisco. So, most of the writing about the midwest and the south is from the perspective of the kids who run away to the coasts. (I did it too.)
Dear Stephen, it is a pleasure to read your blog.
I do not know why is it the runaway kids have more perpective on the places they run away from...I heard the South and Mid-West in America have seen the birth of a lot of American culture. I would love to see that part of the world.
it is true - not only is popular woldview of India being defined by the diaspora - but also it seems to me that they have a rather 'frozen' image of India - as in, more a country / socety of their memories and dreams than the actual state it is in - the cultural conflicts within, the changes that are happening
I guess that is what you meant by -"too ethnic to a point of being termed backward in the modern context" - as a resident Indian, I sometimes do resent their presumptions about this country....
Thank Charu you summed it all up well...
Your site is amazing! i want to come back for visiting your site.Keep doing Good as
Post a Comment
<< Home